What Makes Someone Identify As Multiracial?

by By
from FiveThirtyEight

The multiracial population, now a small subset of the nation, is growing at three times the rate of the general population, according to a report from the Pew Research Center released Thursday. And as the group continues to grow, so does our ability to study the diversity of its members’ experiences.

The most comprehensive historical data we have on the subject is from the Census Bureau, but that data is murky at best. Racial categories on the decennial census have changed dramatically over the years (shoutout to the 1860 options of “black,” “white” and “mulatto.”) There’s also the question of whether or not Hispanic should count as a race. (The Census Bureau considers it an ethnicity, and says Hispanics can be of any race.) And then there’s self-identification: If someone has parents of different races, but she doesn’t consider herself mixed-race, how should she be categorized?

munguia-datlab-multiracial
The introduction of an option for “two or more races” on the 2000 census opened up a new avenue for studying the growing group of multiracial Americans. That year, 2.4 percent of people chose to identify as multiracial. Ten years later, about 2.9 percent of people chose more than one racial group. Across every racial group, young people were more likely to identify as multiracial.

The Pew survey used a broader definition than self-identification; it also took into account people who said they have one parent or even one grandparent of a different race. Under that definition, but maintaining the census race categories, the report found that 6.9 percent of American adults are multiracial. If “Hispanic” were included as a race, that share would grow to 8.9 percent.

If determining how to define “multiracial” is difficult, then pinning down a central, shared experience of the multiracial population (on anything from discrimination to acceptance) is impossible. Pew’s associate director, Juliana Menasce Horowitz, said that one of the most surprising findings of the report is just how differently the distinct racial subsets answered questions about their identity and experiences. “People generally tend to think of race as something that’s absolute,” Horowitz said. “But our findings show just how fluid racial identity and the associated experiences can be.”

While only 22 percent of those Pew defines as multiracial would categorize themselves that way, those who have a white-Asian background were the most likely to self-identify as multiracial, and those who have a black-American Indian background were the least likely to do so.

Screen Shot 2015-06-10 at 3.05.29 PM

Similarly, each group has vastly different experiences with discrimination and acceptance. Biracial black-white adults are more likely to feel accepted by blacks than by whites. More multiracial Hispanics feel they have a lot in common with whites than feel they have a lot in common with Hispanics. Only 13 percent of people who are biracial black-American Indian feel they have much in common with American Indians.

These findings are consistent within subsets of the multiracial population, but there’s almost no pattern of similarity for the broader group. Even when asked something as broad as whether or not people were confused by their background, answers varied widely by racial subset.

Screen Shot 2015-06-10 at 3.26.29 PM

The diversity of experience may come because less than a third of the general population considers racial background to be important to their identity, and that share is even lower for multiracial adults.

Screen Shot 2015-06-10 at 3.28.34 PM

Pew says this study is the first of its kind, so it’s hard to put any of this data in historical context (other than the census’s limited definition). But Horowitz hopes the report will be just the beginning of this type of analysis.

“It’s a growing population, so it’s a natural topic of research for us,” Horowitz said. “As the population continues to grow, it’ll become even easier to conduct analysis on specific groups, and the information we can gather on subgroups will become even more robust.”

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s